I am honored to have received an invitation from BzzAgent’s Founder/CEO Dave Balter to review the private beta for the new product they are launching, called BzzScapes. I was invited with eleven other people, and am truly excited by this site, so wanted to talk a bit about it.

First… what is BzzAgent?  It’s a word of mouth marketing company.  The way it works, is that people sign up to be an “agent” for a particular brand’s campaign, they receive materials in the mail, and then report on their experiences.  For example, a few months back, I was an agent for the Boston Market campaign BzzScapes(completely unrelated to my Twitter name of @BostonMarketer!).  I received a package in the mail that educated me about Boston Market and gave me coupons to use. I was supposed to use the coupons and buy the product, and then report my experiences with the brand and with telling other people about the brand.  This model is incredibly successful at spreading the word about products and services.

About BzzScapes

But, being immersed in the online world, I had been surprised that BzzAgent didn’t have more of an online presence or plan for using online for word of mouth.  BzzScapes is their first answer to that question, with online communities that allow consumers to create, add to and interact with the brand “Scape”.  Consumers create a central place for content they find about brands they are interested in.  They can upload their favorite photos, videos, experiences, websites, etc. Anyone can create a Scape for a brand, anyone can add content to a Scape, and anyone can rate/review the content.  Community members can “follow” brands so they are updated when new content is added, and also follow and communicate with other community members.  The site has only been in beta testing until its launch this morning, but there are currently three thousand community members, 300 Scapes and 4,000 pieces of content already on the site.

Apple BzzScape

All of this is free to the consumers and free to the brands, as it is all user uploaded content.  However, if a brand chooses to, they can pay BzzAgent $5,000/month to “activate” their brand, which gives them additional services.  For activated brands, BzzAgent will upload the brand’s content into the BzzScape (only consumers can rate content though).  The brand will also be promoted in certain areas throughout the site and in BzzAgent emails.  And, most importantly, the brand gets access to consumers, so can poll them, ask them questions and test out new ideas.  A brand can also pay BzzAgent to find new users for its Scape.


I LOVE the idea of BzzScapes, and think it is interesting from both the consumer and brand perspectives.

Consumer perspective

For consumers, this platform is interesting, as it allows people to connect with a brand and shape the way the Scape looks, without a corporate influence. Consumers have the opportunity to become an opinion leader in the eyes of the brand and other consumers.  And, they can connect with others who have a passion for the brand.

Brand perspective

For brands, this is like free marketing research.  They can see what consumers are uploading and how they are rating these items, which can provide valuable information about where people are focusing their attention.  Its giving the brand a window into the minds of people who want to engage with the brand. It can also help enhance a consumer’s loyalty and passion for the brand, by seeing more content about it.  With the “activation” option, having the ability to find your top supporters and detractors is something that often times can be difficult to do.  In addition, since each item is categorized into “type” (good, bad, why you buy, etc.), brands can track changes in the sentiment about the brand over time.

Another benefit to the brand is that bringing all this content together in one place will certainly have an impact in search engine rankings.

Landscape view of the Lego brand

Landscape view of the Lego brand

My overall thoughts

I think this is an incredibly exciting and innovative way to build an online community, with content as opposed to conversation.  As a marketer, the benefits of being able to use the information in the BzzScape is a great addition to other research and data.  And, being able to reach out to supporters/detractors is invaluable.  Like any research, however, it needs to be looked at in a context of other data, and analyzed for it’s inherent potential biases.  For example, I would imagine that people who participate in a Scape will more likely than not be passionate fans, and secondly passionate detractors, but not much in the middle.

I also see the Scapes as encouraging loyalty solely by people participating in the Scape.  By talking to others, seeing more content, they may become even more loyal.

A primary way I see these Scapes Arrested Developmentbecoming viral is for people to use the Share  feature in BzzScapes, where you can click a button to share content on Facebook, Twitter, Digg, Delicious, etc.  The sharing option is there, but could be beefed up on the site a bit more, by suggesting sharing when a person is engaged with rating or commenting.

One concern I had is surrounding transparency, which is something important for success in social media.  I was concerned that consumers would think that the brand owners rated their content highly in order to make their BzzScape look more favorable.  But, Dave educated me that brands that are “activated” are not able to rate their own content (they can just add content).  I think this is something that needs to be communicated, to educate consumers that the Scapes are consumer generated and driven.

In order to start a new Scape and have it visible to others, a consumer needs to upload five pieces of content, which seems to be a high barrier to participation.  I’m not sure why there needs to be a limit, but if there is, I believe that three would be more reasonable.

What do you think of this new product?  How do you see it being used?  Would you participate as a consumer or as a brand owner?

Share This:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • MySpace
  • Ping.fm
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • PDF
  • Tumblr
  • Print
  • email
  • staceykhart211
    The barge and rail system could also face challenges on profitability. “We’d like to take a free market approach. If rails and barges can be amtrak promotion code supported in the free market, then that’s fine,” he said, explaining he wouldn’t want to see another “Amtrak.”
  • Hi Michael,

    I wanted to address you personally on here in the event that you happen to check back. First apologies if no one replied back to you.

    And...

    Please by all means email directly at itsmejono at bzzagent dot com and I'd be happy to speak with you and/or direct you to the right folks at BzzAgent who handle inbound campaign requests.

    Thanks!
    Jono
  • Lorelei Grazier
    Thanks for sharing the new info. On my end, I am not sure if I would take the time to create a profile or add to one for a company that I already love. (I too love Apple.) Though I would defend them if I saw a bad review and felt they needed a boost.

    I have recently had a bad experience with AmTrak and my first thought while reading your review was that I should check to see if they are listed and let them know what happened. I do like AmTrak in general, but I have recently had a bad experience that I want to communicate it to them so that it can be rectified. Their customer service has not returned my messages - though I get the automatically generated reply that someone will reach me in 24 hours...

    So I agree with a lot of what Jeff said. Transparency is key, and if a company can pay to get some help, it seems less genuine.
  • michael
    I signed up for the original (not this new version obviously) and thought it was a crock.

    The website is hard to navigate. If you are coming into this cold, they do a piss-poor job of explaining what they do. Then they send you campaigns (not too many which is good) but it's confusing. Am I supposed to DO something? Does that count as an impression that I got a mail? What? It's not clear.

    Then I contacted them about doing a campaign. I got one from one of my competitors so thought I might give it a shot.

    No response from them.

    Will not be using this any time soon.

    Michael
  • Michael - Sorry to hear you had a bad experience. I don't work there, so I can't respond for BzzAgent, but my guess is that they'll be reading this!
  • Great review of BzzScapes! BzzAgent has been an innovator and leader in the Word of Mouth Marketing arena. So I think it's fantastic to see the company take a much more active role online. Long overdue, in my opinion.

    <abbr>Warren Sukernek’s last blog post..WOMMA rocks South Beach: Inside the numbers</abbr>
  • Rachel - great way to break this down and spark some interest on the value of building conversation hubs like BzzScapes.

    I think BzzAgent would be wise to promote the hell outta this for the primary reason that they need a high volume of users to create a robust and active community.

    Brands will not only learn what fans think of them, they will learn about their own brand - a lot of times what we put out there and how its perceived and used doesn't show up in a marketing report or old school methods like a (blech) two-way mirrored focus group.

    And the bigger the community, the more the community takes control over brand bashing (to counterpoint Adamg's point). Companies like Target aren't afraid to really put it out there - last time I was on their Facebook page, the top comment was, "Target sucks." Good for them for leaving it there and letting the masses respond and decide for ourselves.
  • Suzi - I couldn't agree more.. the great thing about letting people comment and rate/review is that you learn something whether it's positive or negative. Tempting to delete, but not wise!
  • My initial thoughts are laced with skepticism, but let's get the niceness out of the way first.

    Great review. I liked how in-depth you got and the way you outlined the whole project.

    Sounds like a site that could certainly have value for companies and for consumers, to a degree.

    Ironically, commenting on your review of the service/site is pretty much the model of BzzScapes. We're giving feedback to them indirectly through you about how they might improve the product.

    Well, here are my thoughts in no particular order because that's how I roll.

    Transparency Fail to a Degree - If you love a product (I love Apple) you're going to be an apologist and defender of the brand no matter what others say. It's tough to be impartial. So I don't think the community aspect of it is going to fly particularly well in that regard. As for reviewers (Bzz'ers), there is definitely going to be skepticism on my part that you're getting paid to say nice things. Coupons, discounts, whatever. If you're getting anything, that damages your impartial stance when sharing info on that company.

    It Already Exists - We have Yelp and the individual sites with which to connect and learn and share about companies. If I'm annoyed with Apple, I go say so on their forums and I post it on the dozens of other boards dedicated to the company. OK, a company as small and as social-media absent as Harpoon or GM might find this site/service as a help, but how valuable can it be if the numbers don't arrive. I don't think I'd use it because I can find out more info from an already vetted user base somewhere else.

    No Model? C'mon - There has got to be a way for BzzScapes to make money down the line. From your notes it looks like their allegiance is going to sway toward the companies with the pay model. That puts the community and consumers like me - looking for transparency - at a disadvantage. Oh, Apple has a paid account? Well then how can I be sure they aren't 'adjusting' the messaging?

    Finally, if BzzScapes and these other companies (and their CMOs) want to leverage community thinking to help their brands or projects, they should cook it themselves. I'm chatting like a CMO right now because of tomorrow's free Webinar.* (see blog post) But I truly believe that valuable info isn't so string-free.

    Please keep us updated on what goes on.

    Also, can you honestly say that coupons from Boston Market didn't influence your meal choices or thoughts? Have you been back? Have they changed things based on your feedback? Were you a customer before? Are you now?

    Thanks!

    Jeff

    <abbr>Jeff Cutler’s last blog post..What? A Webinar? Why and for Whom</abbr>
  • Jeff - Thanks for your comment! Wow, how thorough. A few comments back...

    Transparency - I probably confused this a bit in my description. The coupons were for BzzAgent's regular word of mouth campaigns. That's what I did with Boston Market. The BzzScape program is not like that. You receive nothing from BzzAgent for participating. But, to answer your questions about my participation in the Boston Market campaign... no, it didn't influence my choices or thoughts. The coupon was for $ off, so I got what I wanted. I haven't been back, but it definitely came back into my consideration set of fast restaurants I would consider. I had forgotten about them. I will say, that I also did have a couple of conversations about them, telling people I liked them. It wasn't anything forced, but it came up in conversation and I talked about my good experience.

    I do agree that reinforcing the transparency is key. BzzAgent needs to reassure consumers that the "activated" brands are not allowed to rate the items.

    Thanks again for your comments!

    It already exists - The difference seems to me to be about the content... people are posting content, not just talking about the brand/company.
  • Very attractive and it will be interesting to see if it picks up with consumers. It sounds like an extended Yelp community only for brands. I know that my nephews (in their late teens) and the Gen Y crowd here in my office enjoy rating and comparing products as well as sharing their experience about those products with others. They tell me that they don’t mind giving out their demographic information because then the messages they receive are targeted to their likes and personal tastes. I’ll check this site out and share it with friends and family.

    <abbr>Jeff Hurt’s last blog post..Ten Ways Twitter Is Like Star Trek</abbr>
  • What's to keep this from becoming a collection of "[Brand] sucks" sites?
  • Good question Adamg - I'm not from the company, so I don't know for sure. But, given that it's community driven, it's certainly possible that certain brands could go in that direction. But, if it's a few vocal negative people only, they will get "voted down" by the other community members. But, if it did all go negative, if I were the brand, I would still be interested in learning what people have to say.
  • Helen
    Hi

    What's in it for the user exactly? Are they being paid to contribute?
  • Helen - No they're not being paid to contribute. It allows them to connect to brands they like or dislike. And, connect to others who do the same. And, if you're a lover of a brand, it's great to learn new things about it! For example, I started the Arrested Development Scape, and yesterday someone posted something I had never seen before.
  • Good in-depth review of Scapes. I'm definitely going to have to check it out -- it sounds like it offers so much more (especially for product/brand fans) than something like a Facebook fan page which is almost tantalizing in its potential power. As a marketer, I have to wonder how much traffic a site like this would divert from my website. If, as a company, I am intent driving traffic to my website, is this a traffic driver, or another destination? (Is traffic one of the things activation offers?)

    Of, course, my immediate question is, can I use it for Mass Innovation Nights?

    <abbr>Bobbie Carlton’s last blog post..Three Questions from Social Media Club Boston</abbr>
  • Thanks for the comment Bobbie! Yes, definitely different from a Facebook fan page, as it's all user uploaded. It's possible it MAY divert traffic from the brand's site, but it will also drive more traffic to the Scape from other brands' Scapes. When people are on the BzzScape website, they will discover other brands' Scapes to participate in. I also think that WHERE people see your content is less important than THAT they see your content.

    And, yes, of course you could use it for Mass Inno! It's a brand too! (and so is Bobbie Carlton)
blog comments powered by Disqus